Show summary Hide summary
- Why custom orders get so weird on OnlyFans
- Foot-related fetishes top the list
- “Eating” requests that shocked performers
- Requests that cross hygiene and dignity lines
- Lighthearted and surreal requests that made performers laugh
- How creators cope with the barrage of odd asks
- Legal, ethical, and platform risks buyers ignore
- Real examples creators shared (paraphrased)
- Why the conversation matters for audiences and platforms
OnlyFans creators routinely face requests that range from odd to outright disturbing. A recent Reddit thread pulled back the curtain on the most bizarre custom orders performers receive. The list shows how anonymous demand can push boundaries, and why many creators now screen fans more carefully.
Why custom orders get so weird on OnlyFans
Creators on subscription platforms offer tailored content to earn more. That freedom also invites unusual demands. Men are often the buyers, and anonymity makes extreme requests easier to send. Moderation, safety, and consent become urgent concerns.
Hilary Swank’s husband Philip Schneider: inside the businessman behind the star
Polska pregnant and betrayed by a close friend: she is very, very shocked
How the market encourages extremes
- Custom videos pay better than standard posts.
- Buyers can ask for anything that won’t get the creator banned.
- Anonymity lowers social norms, so some requests escalate quickly.
Foot-related fetishes top the list
Many creators said feet-centered asks are the most common. These range from the tame to the absurd.
- Requests to press down on small creatures or objects while narrating cheerfully.
- Fans asking for barefoot driving or staged danger with cars.
- Demands for extended close-ups and step-by-step sequences focused on toes and soles.
Performers noted these requests can feel degrading or unsafe, especially when they involve live animals or real risk.
“Eating” requests that shocked performers
Consumption-based fetishes are another frequent category. Some asks involve unusual props. Others veer into harmful territory.
- Fans asking creators to chew or swallow odd items, including live creatures.
- Pregnant creators receiving requests designed to fetishize fetal movement.
- Demands to handle raw meat or mimic animalistic behavior for the camera.
Several creators described feeling disturbed or pressured by these demands. Health and legal risks are common concerns.
Requests that cross hygiene and dignity lines
Some submissions focus less on fantasy and more on shock value. These tend to involve bodily fluids or messy scenarios.
- Asks to cover the body with food products and then perform explicit actions.
- Fans requesting simulated bodily functions or the deliberate soiling of clothing.
- Demands that pair mess with choreography or narration for hours-long videos.
Creators often decline these orders. Many report blocking repeat offenders or adding strict custom policies.
Lighthearted and surreal requests that made performers laugh
Not every custom ask is gross. Some are whimsical, odd, or outright comedic.
- Fans requesting role-play where the performer pretends to be a candy or toy.
- Requests for mundane actions made erotic, like bathing fully clothed or getting stuck in household props.
- Playful commissions: puppet-guided tutorials, costumed skits, or vintage-style show-and-tell.
Those lighter requests can be lucrative and safe. Creators say they prefer playful commissions over degrading ones.
How creators cope with the barrage of odd asks
Veteran performers use several tactics to manage custom work. They set firm boundaries and use prewritten policies.
- Clear price lists with explicit do-not-do items.
- Scripts and templates to filter out unrealistic or unsafe requests.
- Screening new buyers, asking for verification, or refusing anonymous commissions.
Community spaces like Reddit help creators share warnings, tactics, and solidarity when things go wrong. Many credit peer advice with preventing harmful encounters.
Legal, ethical, and platform risks buyers ignore
Some requests may breach local laws or platform rules. Creators face consequences if they comply.
- Performing acts that involve protected wildlife or food safety laws.
- Producing content that could be classified as harmful or exploitative.
- Violating site terms, which can lead to bans and lost income.
Creators balance earning potential against long-term safety. They often consult other performers before accepting unusual orders.
Real examples creators shared (paraphrased)
- A buyer asked for a staged scene where the performer steps on tiny animals while speaking playfully.
- One person described a request to ingest objects so movement could be heard later during pregnancy.
- Requests to squeeze food into containers and ship it were reported more than once.
- Some fans asked for simulated accidents in props like cat trees or for performers to act trapped.
- Other orders combined costume play, puppetry, and bodily acts into elaborate role-plays.
Creators often rewrite or refuse these briefs to protect themselves, their reputation, and their health.
Why the conversation matters for audiences and platforms
These stories highlight a clash between buyer demand and creator safety. Platforms must balance creator freedom with effective moderation. Audiences should recognize that behind every request is a real person making decisions about risk.
